Skip to main content
Old Testament Reflections

“To the Thousandth Generation”

Reflections on Jonah

Illustration of Jonah preaching to a crowd in Nineveh, with the city’s buildings behind them.
AI-generated illustration of Jonah preaching repentance to the people of Nineveh.
Photo by T Studio/stock.adobe.com*

One highlight of reading the Old Testament this year has been recognizing patterns in the prophets' stories. In a previous post, “Zeal and the Still Small Voice,” I noted parallels between Elijah and Moses that seem deliberately woven into Elijah's story as he flees for his life and meditates in a cave. This week’s reading connects that same Elijah story to the tale of another prophet, Jonah, in telling ways. So, I want to explore that comparison and then extend it one step further to the prophet of the Restoration, Joseph Smith (a long-distance jump, I recognize, but hear me out). The pattern I’m noticing isn’t necessarily a flattering one, but it is certainly relatable, which makes it all the more valuable for us readers.

In the case of Elijah, we saw the Lord interrogating the zeal Elijah claimed he had for the Lord of Hosts in putting 450 prophets of Baal to death. The Lord juxtaposes the prophet’s violence with not a wind, not an earthquake, not a fire, but with a still small voice, a lesson that Elijah seems reluctant to take on board, since he only reiterates his zeal for the Lord of Hosts even after that dramatic object lesson (1 Kings 18:40; 1 Kings 19:9–14).

Now we come to the story of Jonah, and once again we meet a man who seems to hold a harsher, more zealous view than God of those whom he rightly regards as in the wrong—in this case, the people of Nineveh. Rather than fulfill the merciful mission the Lord gives him, calling them to repentance, Jonah famously tries to flee and is brought back to his task only through the good offices of a great fish prepared by God. When he finally does as he was asked, Jonah is dismayed when the city responds with repentance, so God decides not to bring upon them the destruction Jonah had foretold (Jonah 1:1–3, 17; 2:10; 3:1–10). When Jonah says, “I knew that you are a gracious and merciful God, slow to anger, abounding in steadfast love” (Jonah 4:2, NRSVue), he means it not as a compliment, but a complaint. God is being too forgiving! And yet he is quoting God’s own self-description to Moses, recorded in Exodus 34:5–7. It’s worth quoting here that original, longer version of what Jonah references in his complaint. It is not a passing comment; it arrives at the tremendous moment when Moses returns to the mount, having already dashed the first set of tablets inscribed with God’s law because he found the children of Israel worshiping the calf of gold they had made in his absence. As God accepts the two new tablets of stone from Moses on which will be re-inscribed the law of the Lord for all of Israel, God utters the sacred name and, repeating it a second and third time, says:

The LORD, the LORD, a God merciful and gracious, slow to anger, and abounding in steadfast love and faithfulness, keeping steadfast love for the thousandth generation, forgiving iniquity and transgression and sin, yet by no means clearing the guilty, but visiting the iniquity of the parents upon the children and the children’s children to the third and the fourth generation. (Exodus 34:6–7, NRSVue)

These are words that would have been etched on Jonah’s heart like the tablets themselves, and yet Jonah is bothered that the Lord is in fact upholding his way of being merciful, gracious, slow to anger, and abounding in steadfast love.

Where Elijah was upset because his action didn’t lead to the people’s repentance, Jonah is upset because his action does. He makes a shelter outside the city, watching and apparently still hoping for its destruction (Jonah 4:5). The scene seems to reprise Elijah in his cave. The plant God prepared (like the fish God had prepared) grows over Jonah to shade him, recalling how Elijah was fed by an angel as he sheltered under a broom tree in the wilderness (1 Kings 19:5–8). The two prophets express their dismay in nearly the same words. Elijah, under his tree, “requested for himself that he might die; and said, It is enough; now, O LORD, take away my life; for I am not better than my fathers” (1 Kings 19:4). Jonah, before the plant has even appeared, prays, “Therefore now, O LORD, take, I beseech thee, my life from me; for it is better for me to die than to live” (Jonah 4:3)—and he will say it a second time once the plant is gone (Jonah 4:8). Together these two prophets represent different faces of a similar zeal. One seizes God’s prerogative for punitive judgment, the other resents God for not exercising it himself.

But as with Elijah, God isn’t done trying to help Jonah learn. Like Elijah, Jonah faces a dramatic object lesson. In his case, a pest destroys the plant that has come up to shade him, and then an east wind pelts Jonah as the sun beats down on him (Jonah 4:6–8). Finally, as with Elijah, God offers his prophet a question for reflection, and I like to imagine it is offered in a still, small voice as it was with Elijah. God asks Jonah if God shouldn’t be as concerned for the welfare of a huge city as for one plant sheltering one man (Jonah 4:10–11). And then the story ends, with that pointed question hanging unanswered, as though it were more important that we, the readers, be left contemplating it than to hear whatever answer Jonah might offer.

These questions for reflection from God resonate across the centuries. They come alive in scenarios where the actors are new, but the problem is old: What shall we do when we want swift vengeance, but the Lord instead works patience and mercy? This enduring problem challenges even the mightiest prophets. Witness the Prophet Joseph Smith, languishing not in a cave, nor under a withered plant, but in a jail ironically named Liberty. His cry, “O God, where art thou?” (D&C 121:1) is a variation on the psalm Christ himself uttered from the cross: “My God, my God, why hast thou forsaken me?” (Psalm 22:1; cf. Mark 15:34). Then, after reciting a litany of very real grievances and wounds (and unlike the Savior who says “Father, forgive them,” Luke 23:34), the prophet succumbs, like his predecessors, to a wish for retribution upon his enemies (“Let thine anger be kindled against our enemies; and, in the fury of thine heart, with thy sword avenge us of our wrongs,” D&C 121:5). The Lord’s response is consistent with the character revealed to the ancient prophets. It is a calming voice, saying, “My son, peace be unto thy soul” (D&C 121:7), and another question for reflection: “The Son of Man hath descended below them all. Art thou greater than he?” (D&C 122:8).1

And here is one more remarkable parallel between Jonah and Joseph. They both acknowledge, even in their lamentation, the finishing virtue of steadfast love. We have already noted Jonah’s citation of Exodus. In Liberty Jail, the Lord urges Joseph: “Let thy bowels also be full of charity towards all men . . .” (emphasis added). I love the word “also” here. To me, it reads as the Lord inviting Joseph to be like himself. He adds an assurance that exercising such love will be transformative: “thy dominion shall be an everlasting dominion, and without compulsory means it shall flow unto thee forever and ever” (D&C 121:45–46). What greater promise can there be? As the God of the Old Testament manifests faithfulness and mercy across the stories of Moses, Elijah, and Jonah, so he reveals himself in “the thousandth generation” since still to be a God who will forbear and wait with patience on his servants as they, and we, learn the ways of steadfast love.

Notes

1. This question is from the same original letter written by Joseph as the other material quoted here, though they are now printed in different sections of the D&C. Return to endnote reference 1 ↩

Old Testament Reflections

Complementing your study of Come, Follow Me.

Morgan Davis

D. Morgan Davis is a Research Fellow at the Neal A. Maxwell Institute for Religious Scholarship. He holds a Ph.D. (2005) in Arabic and Islamic studies from the University of Utah, an M.A. in history from the University of Texas at Austin, and a B.A. in Near Eastern Studies from Brigham Young University.