The Wonder of Scripture with J. Spencer Fluhman
Introduction by Rosalynde Welch
It is truly my joy and my honor to introduce Dr. Spencer Fluhman, currently chair of the Department of History at Brigham Young University and former executive director of the Maxwell Institute.
This morning I looked back through my email to find the first email I ever exchanged with Spencer. I thought I knew what it was, but I was wrong. As Spencer knows as a historian, our memories are often incorrect. We exchanged emails in 2011 about a symposium in honor of Richard Bushman that Spencer helped organize and in which I participated. I had forgotten that. My memory of the advent of our friendship is from 2016. If you’ll indulge me in a little personal history, it will tell you a lot about Spencer.
I did my undergraduate work here, then went straight into a PhD program in early modern English literature. I decided not to enter the academic job market; I wanted to have more children. For about two decades, I worked as an independent scholar out in St. Louis, Missouri, far from the center of Latter-day Saint intellectual life. I was fortunate that this happened as the online world of Latter-day Saint thought was exploding. I found ways to get involved and wonderful mentors and colleagues, though I was always somewhat on the margins. It was an incredibly rewarding time in my life.
Around 2016, I decided to write an article about a new current in Latter-day Saint thought that I was fortunate to be part of and to observe closely: a new kind of Latter-day Saint theology, deeply rooted in scripture, bringing critical tools and perspectives to bear, and committed to the metaphysical materialism of Joseph Smith’s revelatory corpus. I wrote a review article unsolicited and sent it cold to the Mormon Studies Review, which is not typically how that journal works. It landed on Spencer’s desk. At the time, he was the newly appointed executive director of the Maxwell Institute and the author of award-winning books and articles, notably A Peculiar People: Anti-Mormonism and the Making of Religion in Nineteenth-Century America. He was also the journal’s editor and director of this new Institute, which he had been charged with transforming from an administrative unit into a full-fledged, top-notch, blue-ribbon, active academic research community.
To accomplish this feat, Spencer drew on his abundant gifts: he noticed and encouraged young scholars; won the attention of seasoned thinkers and sought their guidance with wit, charm, and intelligence; petitioned the Lord for inspired visions to pursue; and, behind the scenes, wielded his administrative wizardry at the levers of bureaucratic power.
He read my article and invited me to meet with him in his office. My life changed from that day forward. Spencer recognized my willingness to contribute to this new conversation and found ways to involve me in the Institute in roles of increasing responsibility. At every step, he mentored me, taught me, encouraged me, and dreamed up projects that made me want to contribute and engage the best of my intellect. Then he did what I never expected. I did not expect ever to come back to the university. If you earn a PhD in the humanities and decide not to enter the academic job market, you realize that you have closed that door for good. I had made peace with that. Spencer found a way to open that door and invite me back into the university community in a surprising twist that I never expected. I still have to pinch myself every day to believe this is real. Thank you will never, never be enough.
Besides shaping the current form of the Institute, including hiring two-thirds of its current personnel, Spencer has made many contributions. I’ll name two highlights. First are the Brief Theological Introductions to the Book of Mormon, the 12-volume series we published in 2020. It was his brainchild and inspiration, and he brought it into the world in truly record time. This is the untold story of the BTIs. It's a landmark in Book of Mormon studies and it's also a landmark of beauty, bringing an aesthetic importance worthy of its subject matter.
The second highlight is Spencer’s burning passion for injecting Zion into every institution he comes in contact with, making sure every voice is included and invited on a free and equal basis, especially voices that have not historically been heard or have been actively excluded. In ways too numerous to recount, he has rooted out racism, sexism, and every form of injustice that still harms our community.
Two more parts of Spencer’s identity are essential to get the full picture of the man. First, he is a total wife guy. He is married to the amazing Hollie Fluhman, and he is besotted with her. Her spirit and goodness have been part of everything he has done. Second, he is a total sneakerhead, and his shoe game is very strong. You’ll notice that today. Please join me in welcoming Spencer Fluhman.
Lecture
I challenged Rosalynde to give a two-sentence introduction because I knew what would happen. When I wonder what I’ve done with my career, sometimes, I look back and think, “Well, I hired Rosalynde Welch.” So that helps.
I am beyond honored to have my name again associated with the Neal A. Maxwell Institute for Religious Scholarship at BYU. You’ll not find anyone more appreciative of its scholars or more supportive of its work.
I intend my comments this morning for you students. There are faculty here, I know, but this is not for them. During the Q&A, in fact, I’ll prioritize student questions.
I taught my first BYU class in “the late 1900s,” and since then I have spent a career reckoning with history, scripture, and the life of faith. This morning, I aim to braid together scholarly ways of thinking with the practice of Latter-day Saint faith—generally speaking, that’s the project I have dedicated my entire life to.
I have been intentional about my title: “‘Build Up My Church’: Practicing Faith at the Intersection of History & Scripture.” By deploying the word “practice,” I hope to nudge us away from abstraction towards the practical living of faith. What follows is shaped by more than two decades of scholarship and interfaith dialogue, but this morning, students, I am just another Latter-day Saint, thinking along with you students about things that matter. (Luckily for you, you don’t have to believe a word I say. I've got some of my students here—you have to believe what I say at 2. Right now, you don't.)
I will have us consider one of the “hard sayings” of Jesus in the Restoration, and then I will model a method of wrestling with it.1 My method is not strictly historical, but it's informed and shaped by the training I have as a professional historian. Because my approach takes the authority of scripture and apostolic teachings seriously, my method is not secular, either. It is “academic adjacent,” at least, what I model today, at least in the sense that it proposes a way of thinking rigorously about scripture. And, because my comments seek Jesus as their ultimate end, my method is not neutral in any sense. I’ll draw liberally on the work of my generation of Latter-day Saint thinkers, who I love and honor for their consecrations of mind and heart. I can never repay the gift it is to love so many of them as friends. In the end, I hope to at least approximate what the Maxwell Institute’s namesake called “disciple-scholarship.”2
Here's the “hard saying” of Jesus that I'll have us consider. In your Pearl of Great Price, the Joseph Smith—History records the narrative of the prophet's First Vision in a way that some of you can probably recite from memory. In what appears now as verse 19, the prophet relates the divine voice answering the question that took him to the grove, mainly, which of all the sects was right? The answer he tells us was a blistering takedown of the Christian world of 1820: “I was answered that I must join none of them, for they were all wrong; and the Personage who addressed me said that all their creeds were an abomination in his sight, that those professors were all corrupt; that they draw near to me with their lips, but their hearts are far from me; they teach for doctrines the commandments of men, having a form of godliness, but they deny the power thereof.”
This passage is hard to forget, both for the bright line it draws between the Restoration and what had preceded it and because, let’s face it, it amounts to what a former colleague lovingly once said of the Book of Mormon: it’s a “public relations nightmare.”3
Here's my thesis: “This passage of scripture is helpfully balanced by other elements in the early Restoration, but I would not jettison it from our inventory.”
Scripture is like a diamond that shimmers brighter under close examination but unexamined scripture shines too. I suspect you've been struck by decontextualized scripture. That passage that just jumps off the page without knowing much about the world behind it or the world within it. You did not invest much time in that. You did not know much about it. But that scripture revealed something true to you about God or yourself or the world when it just leapt off the page or, ugh, off the screen. Gross.
I hope we never lose our capacity to be startled by the beauty and power of scripture. But, again, often it’s the closer study that throws back the revelatory curtains. Sometimes, in fact, the disciplined seeking is prerequisite for learning or growth. In your religion and your history courses—and, okay, maybe occasionally in your other courses—you’re learning the methods of analysis that will deepen and enrich your study of scripture. You’re learning how to learn by study and by faith.
So, as I historicize and contextualize this passage from Joseph Smith’s history, remember that the method is historically informed, but that's not the end. I’m not merely hoping you’ll more often read contextually. Instead, I’m urging us to read holistically. The end, always, is Christ, and my holistic reading today seeks him as its goal.
Your exploration of this Pearl of Great Price passage would eventually lead you to the realization that it was not originally offered as scripture at all. It was initially a work of institutional history. In 1838, Joseph Smith began again to record an account of the Church’s progress. I say “again” because it was one of several attempts to fulfill the divine commission at the Church’s formation that “there shall be a record kept among you.”4 He had started similar projects in 1832 and 1834. You can review three early drafts of his 1838 history on the Joseph Smith Papers website. The original manuscript that Joseph Smith and his counselor in the First Presidency created together is lost to history, but those later drafts remain. Both drafts #2 and #3 contain the gist of the language we now have in our Pearl of Great Price, but it is draft #2 that we read on the page. In draft #3, a secretary had trimmed some of Joseph Smith's account. (Can you imagine editing the prophet—the hubris! Just kidding, it was his job.) He shortened the account a bit, but that version didn’t make the cut. On the screen is the earliest version of the scripture text that we have, then: a likely copy of a missing original manuscript, in the handwriting of two of Joseph Smith’s secretaries.5
In your exploration you might also be struck by the fact that it was later Church leaders who felt inspired to canonize this portion of Joseph Smith’s history. Apostolic figures stretching from Orson Pratt to Franklin D. Richards, then on to George Q. Cannon, Joseph F. Smith, and John Taylor, ensured that the text was preserved, remembered, treasured, and, eventually, added to our scriptural canon in 1880, some four decades after it was dictated. Together, these later apostles changed the text’s status from history to scripture.6
In your study, you would also find that this famous 1838 account belongs not only to the genre of Joseph Smith’s historical projects, but to a “sub-genre” of First Vision accounts. Nine different accounts are contemporaneous with the Prophet’s life. The first was penned a dozen years after the Vision itself, in 1832. No other version of the account includes the language of “abominable” creeds and “corrupt” teachers of religion, but the 1832 account still provides an arguably milder but still direct account of Christian apostasy. Interestingly, the Prophet relates in this earliest version that he’d come to this conclusion on his own, before God’s declaration. He wrote,
by searching the scriptures I found that
mand<mankind> did not come unto the Lord but that they had apostatised from the true and liveing faith and there was no society or denomination that built upon the gospel of Jesus Christ as recorded in the new testament and I felt to mourn for my own sins and for the sins of the world.7
Then the Vision bursts upon him and the Lord validates that youthful conclusion:
<behold> the world lieth in sin and at this time and none doeth good no not one they have turned asside from the gospel and keep not <my> commandments they draw near to me with their lips while their hearts are far from me and mine anger is kindling against the inhabitants of the earth.
The subsequent 1835 account makes no reference to these matters. (It was recorded by a secretary present at a private conversation between the Prophet and a visitor, and perhaps there just wasn’t time given the setting for a fuller account. We don't know.) In the 1842 account, published in Nauvoo’s newspaper, the Prophet’s narrative again included apostasy language. The Prophet’s relationship to the text isn’t entirely clear, but he was at least comfortable having it appear over his signature. Some of this account closely resembles a missionary tract published earlier by Orson Pratt. That was the first published account of the First Vision in the Restoration. So we're left to wonder if Elder Pratt was reproducing some source from the Prophet we no longer have or if the Prophet simply liked the way Elder Pratt phrased things. At any rate, the 1842 account relates that the Father and Son,
told me that all religious denominations were believing in incorrect doctrines, and that none of them was acknowledged of God as his church and kingdom. And I was expressly commanded to “go not after them,” at the same time receiving a promise that the fulness of the gospel should at some future time be made known unto me.
In 1843, Levi Richards recorded in his Nauvoo journal a portion of a sermon delivered by the Prophet in which he gave a First Vision account. In that brief journal entry, we get this: “received for answer that none of them were right, that they were all wrong, & that the Everlasting covena[n]t was broken.” That same year, a reporter for the Pittsburgh Weekly Gazette published his interview with Joseph Smith. He reported the Prophet saying,
I kneeled down, and prayed, saying, “O Lord, what Church shall I join.” Directly I saw a light, and then a glorious personage in the light, then another personage, and then the first personage said to the second, “Behold my beloved Son, hear him.” I then, addressed this second person, saying, “O Lord, what Church shall I join?” He replied, “don’t join any of them, they are all corrupt.”
The last account of the First Vision recorded during the Prophet’s lifetime was made by a Prussian convert to the Church who had emigrated to Nauvoo. In broken English, he recorded this line, “Mr Smith then asked must I join the Methodist Church= No= they are not my People, th all have gone astray there is none that doeth good no not one.”
So, taking the accounts together, it is clear that a narrative of Christian apostasy was central to the way Joseph Smith understood and communicated his first visionary experience. He returns to it in all but one of them. It’s also evident to me, at least, that the 1838 version ranks as the most visceral and critical, and perhaps the most emotional, too. As we wrestle with the differences between these accounts, we might be struck that the Prophet’s 1838 history itself starts with a sentence that resonates conspicuously with the tone—the vibe— of its comparatively sharp-edged First Vision language.
Owing to the many reports which have been put in circulation by evil disposed and designing persons in relation to the rise and progress of the Church of Latter day Saints, all of which have been designed by the authors thereof to militate against its character as a church, and its progress in the world; I have been induced to write this history so as to disabuse the publick mind, and put all enquirers after truth into possession of the facts as they have transpired in relation both to myself and the Church as far as I have such facts in possession.8
Sweet mercy—that's a sentence! Look it over. How’s that for an opening sentence? Basically the same as Saints? No! It's not. The entire historical project in 1838 then is defensive, given the Prophet’s framing here. To my eye, the 1838 history is the one most laced with pain. It was crafted, after all, in the shadow of one forced evacuation and during the building turmoil of another one. It is tinted with violence and blood. It’s literarily akin to the anguished soul cry of the Prophet’s letter from Liberty Jail that you now treasure as Doctrine and Covenants 121.
This 1838 history is so laced with defensiveness and anger, in fact, that the secretary that I mentioned before, not only trimmed some of the First Vision language, he trimmed passage after passage of that early draft, obviously attempting to tone the prophet's rhetoric down. You can see what he's crossing out on the Joseph Smith Papers and you'll know what I mean. He is toning down that pain and that anguish and that anger.
So, we are left to wonder if the Prophet’s 1838 language was at least partially contextual. If it was, then he appears to have been fully human. Scholars have demonstrated that all memory is shaped by current concerns. That’s how the human brain works. This goes a long way in helping us understand the differences between the First Vision accounts, for one, and for the pulsating intensity of the 1838 narrative, in particular.9
If our contextual frame pans back a little, we encounter early revelations with connections to these themes. If it pans back even further, we confront non-scriptural statements of Joseph Smith that navigate these same waters. Among that small pile of sources, we would find a range of statements, metaphors, and approaches. But if we hunt for some specific, systematic, theological take-down of those abominable creeds from Joseph Smith, we’ll be disappointed, though. Joseph Smith apparently spent little or no time on such things. Instead, what we get from the Prophet is obvious discomfort with creedalism. By that, I mean that the Prophet more often worried about the way creeds or formal confessions of faith might act to limit revelation. For example, a clerk recorded the Prophet as claiming that the “most prominent point of difference in sentiment between the Latter Day Saints & sectarians was, that the latter were circu[m]scribed by some peculiar creed, which deprived its members of the privilege of believing any thing not contained therein; whereas the L. D. Saints had no creed, but are ready to believe all true principles that exist, as they are made manifest from time to time.” That's Joseph Smith off the chain of creeds. It's almost a more method question than a content question. If you dig it.10
If we’ve only ever read the 1838 First Vision account, we might be surprised by some statements from Joseph Smith. Here’s one example among several we might consider. A renowned Methodist preacher related in his autobiography an exchange he had with the Prophet in Illinois. He wrote that the Prophet “believed that among all the Churches in the world the Methodist was the nearest right.” Cartwright quoted the Prophet as concluding, “We Latter-day Saints are Methodists, as far as they have gone, only we have advanced further.”11 (Given the Church’s unpopularity, Carwright had little to gain by relating this slightly backhanded compliment, so there is little reason to doubt his account.)
What makes sense of the Prophet’s generosity here? How might we understand the affinity he perceived between the Restoration and Methodism? Luckily, other Restoration sources provide additional lenses for us.
Perhaps the most profound sits somewhat unobtrusively in one of our earliest recorded revelations. Its language is by comparison gentler, mild, and more inclusive. It resonates with the Prophet’s conversation with that Methodist preacher. A year before the Church was organized, Joseph Smith dictated what we now have as Doctrine and Covenants 10. The earliest manuscript appears on the screen. Speaking of the Book of Mormon, the revelation presents the Lord’s voice as saying, starting in our verse 52,
Behold according to their faith in their Prayers will I bring this part of my Gospel to the knowledge of my People Behold I do not bring it to destroy that which they have received but to build it up & for this cause have I said if this generation harden not their hearts I will establish my Church among them now I do not say this to destroy my Church but I say this to build up my Church therefore whosoever belongeth to my Church need not fear for such shall inherit the Kingdom of Heaven but it is they which do not fear me neither keep my commandments but buildeth up Churches unto themselves to get gain.
I have highlighted the phrases that might stop us in our tracks when reading this in context. Dictated before the Church was organized, the divine voice seems to contradict itself ... unless, that is, some church was already in existence in 1829 that God here owns as his. When you read it through again, it’s clear that’s precisely what’s happening. Before the Church’s organization, God acknowledges two broad churches or kinds of churches then in existence, ones that are built up to get gain and that do not fear God, and one that is his. The Restoration, according to D&C 10, would build that latter church up.
So, if the 1838 First Vision account might lead us to sense of a “great apostasy” in antiquity where the lights simply go out, fully and finally, Doctrine & Covenants 10 gives us a slightly different model of apostasy. It presents us one that was never absolute. Its version of apostasy reminds me of what prophets and apostles have recently stressed about the Restoration, that it is ongoing and incomplete, and more of a process than an event.12 D&C 10 proposes this sort of apostasy.
Had there been critical losses, according to the revelation? Yes. And a pressing need for a Restoration? Goodness, yes, that’s the point of the section. But does it require you or me to take a necessarily hostile or dismissive position with regards to the Christianities that predated the Restoration? No! It doesn't. It acknowledges that God’s people, or his church in a lowercase “c” sense, persisted from antiquity to 1829. The section inspires profound caution in me as a Latter-day Saint historian, lest I tread heavily on God’s church in the past or present.13 In 1978, the First Presidency echoed D&C 10 when it offered a framework for understanding the world’s religious history. They wrote,
The great religious leaders of the world, such as Mohammed, Confucius, and the Reformers
... received a portion of God’s light. Moral truths were given to them by God to enlighten whole nations and to bring a higher level of understanding to individuals.
I will confess, I did not always have so expansive a view as this First Presidency statement. As a young missionary, I remember reading and sharing that Pearl of Great Price verses somewhat polemically, that is, to strongly rebut those critical of the church or to aggressively defend the Restoration. Can you imagine this energy on someone's doorstep? Heaven bless those sweet Virginians. They weren't ready for this. Neither was I, so I guess it's fair. I probably wasn’t a full-blown polemicist back then, but early on I sometimes viewed other religions past and present ungenerously or combatively.
I now see polemics for what they are. They get their power from the emotional reactions they inspire. They trigger.
They can motivate and mobilize. They can be memorable or handy encapsulations of strongly held positions. Thinking again of Joseph Smith, polemics can also forcefully express pain or outrage at mistreatment or oppression.
But polemics have downsides, though. They tend towards the superficial. They often reinforce what hearers already think. They are routinely framed to dismiss or even distort. They can distort or obscure as much as they reveal. Given the exploration I have traced here, it won’t surprise you to know that I no longer deploy the Pearl of Great Price account polemically. Contextualized and balanced by these other Restoration sources, that 1838 account forms an important pole for me still, but it’s not the only note in the symphony.
This has been important for me as a student and teacher of religious history. Imagine my students’ conundrum when I have them review various historical Christian creeds as part of our courses. Here’s an image of one collection of Christian creeds, with Joseph Smith conspicuously perched just beyond the volumes! This is no small corpus, in other words. That's a huge corpus. That's a lot of Christians seeking to understand God over the years.
When my students wrestle with the Apostles’ Creed, for instance, one of the most ancient Christian statements of faith, they struggle to find anything “abominable” at all, especially once they realize that the reference to the “catholic Church” in line fourteen on your screen simply means “universal” in its ancient context. I asked my recent London Centre students to offer a theological critique of the creed, which, of course, they could not do. As my students over the years have delved in the Christian past, they have regularly found much to commend. They have also found positions they cannot assent to given Latter-day Saint teachings, but sometimes even in those cases they still resonate with the animating spirit behind a particular stance. The famous (or infamous for Latter-day Saints) Nicene Creed is a good example. They can find language or concepts that sound foreign to their Latter-day Saint sensibilities, but they tend to side with the majority position in the end, which sought first and foremost to protect Christ’s divinity.
Together we have found ample evidence for something like God’s church having survived to 1830, as D&C 10 suggests. The decades I have spent in the histories before the Restoration have introduced me time and again to God’s cultivation and renewal of his church. I have found faith, hope, and charity all around. I have found friends and fellow travelers. I have found God at work, everywhere. I have been reminded often of Christ’s self-description in the Book of Mormon, “I am the God ... of the whole earth.”14 I have encountered Christ in the histories of the varied groups seeking to follow him, and in the histories of those who have not. History has revealed to me a revealer God who lovingly returns to his vineyard, time and time and time again.
And there I have found powerful motivation to live the Gospel of Jesus Christ. I have been spurred to repentance and renewal myself. What Elder Neal A. Maxwell said more than three decades ago has proven true for me: “I rejoice in the good works and the voices of faith of many in other religions... So many honorable individuals in the world do so much without what we, as members, call ‘gospel fulness,’ while some of us, unfortunately, do so little with so much!”15 I have found that navigating the long story of Christian faith has demanded much more than polemics from me. It has demanded care, rigor, compassion, generosity, and courage. Ultimately, it has formed humility and charity in me.
I will add a note or two here that gets us towards practical considerations. Most of us do not need academic perspectives on broader Christianity for our testimonies of the Restoration. I can admit that now. One can develop a vibrant faith without rigorously engaging our history or anyone else’s, I suppose. (Maybe?) But let’s also be clear that most of us are not prepared to offer reasoned or informed public critiques of the broader Christian tradition.
In other words, our testimonies of the Restoration do not depend on informed perspectives of other faiths, but responsible public discourse sure might. Authentically Christian communication across traditions just might require it. And we better believe that peacemaking along the lines that Presidents Nelson and Oaks have invited us to lead out in surely depend on our ability to offer informed, reasoned responses to those outside the Church. Basic understanding of, and generosity for, our neighbors’ faith seems like a necessary foundation for fairness and peacemaking. The Christian ethic of charity might require more effort than most of us have expended to truly understand, and thus truly love, our neighbors. Certainly, if we bristle under the weight of stereotypes and caricatures, we must not perpetrate them on others.
I conclude this practical section with an even more daring suggestion, that responsible representation of our own faith in public might also demand that we know something about the broader religious and non-religious worlds around us. We might need to know more. We might need to know context before we can responsibly represent ourselves. Welcome to the university! To personalize this and reframe it, I can say that, to my eye, the Restoration’s gems are even more luminous when viewed in context. Historical perspective has helped me discern more clearly what is truly unique and urgent about our true and living Church.
So, this morning I’ve led us to a paradox. We should respect and value those survivals of God’s church that existed before 1830 but proclaim the Restoration as God’s new and urgent work in the world. I have asked us to hold together some seeming contradictions, perhaps. With this kind of intellectual and spiritual wrestle, are we “proving contraries?” Yes, we are, and this, I submit, is a foundational “gospel methodology.”16
Some of you will recognize that language of “proving contraries.” Weeks before his death, Joseph Smith wrote to an editor of a religious reference book that “by p[r]oving contrarreties, truth is made manifest.” What I’ve done here, then, is to apply Joseph Smith’s own method of proving contraries to the revelations that flowed from his prophetic soul. If I am asking us to hold, simultaneously, both warm affinity for, and principled critique of, the broader Christian world, it is because that’s where Restoration scripture places us. We are to be fearless in proclaiming God’s urgent work in the Restoration and wise and discerning with other faiths, always ready to learn from holy men and women outside the Church that we don’t yet know, to paraphrase still another of the Prophet’s revelations.17 I hope I have made clear that historical inquiry of this sort is not merely fun, though it is fantastically that. It’s not merely historical, either. Transformation and holiness await us on the other side of this wrestle between what we share with Christians across time and space, and what we offer them.
In conclusion, I will remind us that the Restoration is bigger and grander than anything we have yet said about it. Elder Maxwell put it this way: “As Latter-day Saints, far from having a doctrinal famine, we do not yet fully sense the soaring comprehensiveness of the Restoration. Provincially, we focus on our own little sectors and their little pieces of gospel tile—without seeing the breathtaking mosaic of the Restoration!”18 Similarly, I am a witness that God is infinitely more than anything we ever say about him. The riches of Christ’s redemption are beyond anything yet written. From where I sit, I am fully stunned by the wonder of it all. I close with a benediction from Elder Maxwell:
We can best express our gratitude for this glorious fulness by developing a more full love for all of humankind. And why not, for the Restoration tells us who our neighbors really are! Let our gratitude likewise be expressed by striving to become, attribute by attribute, more and more as Jesus is (see 3 Ne. 27:27). By so living, ours will not then be a mere appreciation of Jesus, nor a modest admiration of Him. Rather, ours will be an adoration of Jesus expressed by our emulation of Him!19
Thank you.
Notes
1. “Hard sayings” paraphrases John 6:60.
2. See Elder Neal A. Maxwell, “The Disciple-Scholar,” in Henry B. Eyring, ed., On Becoming a Disciple-Scholar (Salt Lake City: Bookcraft, 1995).
3. Joseph Fielding McConkie, “The First Vision and Religious Tolerance,” in Kent P. Jackson and Andrew C. Skinner, eds., A Witness for the Restoration: Essays in Honor of Robert J. Matthews (Provo: Religious Studies Center, 2007), 192.
4. Doctrine & Covenants 21:1.
5. See Karen Lynn Davidson, David J. Whittaker, Mark Ashurst-McGee, and Richard L. Jensen, eds., Histories, Volume 1: 1832–1844, Vol. 1 of The Joseph Smith Papers, Histories, ed. Dean C. Jessee, et al. (Salt Lake City: Church Historian’s Press, 2012), 186–215.
6. See Terryl L. Givens, with Brian M. Hauglid, The Pearl of Greatest Price: Mormonism’s Most Controversial Scripture (New York: Oxford University Press, 2019), 223–40; Russ K. Bennett, “Joseph Smith—History: From Dictation to Canon,” MA Thesis, Department of Religious Education, Brigham Young University, 2012.
7. For the various First Vision accounts, see https://www.josephsmithpapers.org/site/accounts-of-the-first-vision.
8. See Karen Lynn Davidson et al., eds., Histories, 1:204.
9. On questions of the First Vision and memory, see Steven C. Harper, First Vision: Memory and Mormon Origins (New York: Oxford University Press, 2019).
10. Quoted in Richard Lyman Bushman, Joseph Smith: Rough Stone Rolling, A Cultural Biography of Mormonism’s Founder (New York: Alfred A. Knopf, 2005), 285.
11. Peter Cartwright, Autobiography of Peter Cartwright, the Backwoods Preacher, ed. W. P. Strickland (Cincinnati: Cranston and Curts, 1856), 342.
12. See, for example, President Dieter F. Uchtdorf, “Are You Sleeping Through the Restoration?” General Conference Address, April 2014 (https://www.churchofjesuschrist.org/study/general-conference/2014/04/are-you-sleeping-through-the-restoration?lang=eng).
13. For scholarly Latter-day Saint approaches to the concept of “apostasy,” see Miranda Wilcox and John D. Young, Standing Apart: Mormon Historical Consciousness and the Concept of Apostasy (New York: Oxford University Press, 2014).
14. 3 Nephi 11:14.
15. Elder Neal A. Maxwell, “From the Beginning,” General Conference Address, October 1993 (https://www.churchofjesuschrist.org/study/general-conference/1993/10/from-the-beginning?lang=eng).
16. President Spencer W. Kimball, “The Second Century of Brigham Young University,” address at Brigham Young University, 10 October 1975 (https://speeches.byu.edu/talks/spencer-w-kimball/second-century-brigham-young-university/).
17. Brett D. Dowdle, Adam H. Petty, J. Chase Kirkham, Elizabeth A. Kuehn, David W. Grua, and Matthew C. Godfrey, eds., Documents, Volume 15: 15 May – 28 June 1844, Vol. 15 of The Joseph Smith Papers, Documents, ed. Matthew C. Godfrey, et al. (Salt Lake City: Church Historian’s Press, 2023), 128–29; Doctrine & Covenants 49:8.
18. Maxwell, “From the Beginning.”
19. Maxwell, “From the Beginning.”